Home » Does It Matter Who Files For Divorce First?

Does it matter who files for divorce first?

Once a marriage is ending, many people wonder if they should hurry to file before their spouse does. Is there an advantage to being first? Will the judge see the person who filed differently?

The short answer: In Illinois, filing first does not give you an advantage on the big issues: property division, support, or parenting time. Those are decided under the same laws no matter who filed. But filing first can affect where and when your case is heard, and it gives you more control over the timing. In some situations, especially when spouses live in different states, that can matter a great deal.

What Filing First Does Not Change

In an Illinois divorce, the spouse who files is called the petitioner, and the other spouse is the respondent. Those labels don’t give either side an edge on the outcome.

  • Illinois is a no-fault state. The only ground for divorce is irreconcilable differences. Filing first doesn’t mean you “win” or that your spouse was at fault.
  • Property is divided the same way. Marital property is divided equitably under the same statute, regardless of who filed.
  • Parenting decisions focus on the children. Judges decide parenting time and decision-making based on the child’s best interests, not on which parent filed.
  • Support follows the guidelines. Child support and maintenance are calculated using Illinois formulas and factors that don’t depend on who filed.
  • The respondent can ask for everything the petitioner can. A respondent can file a counter-petition and request their own relief on every issue.

Possible Advantages of Filing First

Choosing Where the Case Is Heard

This is often the biggest practical advantage, and it matters in the Metro East. If you and your spouse live in different states, such as one in Belleville and one in St. Louis, the spouse who files first may be able to choose which state handles the divorce, as long as residency requirements are met. Illinois and Missouri have different laws on property division, maintenance, and other issues, so the choice of state can affect the outcome.

The same can be true for military families. Service members stationed at Scott Air Force Base may have more than one state where a divorce could be filed. See Stationed at Scott AFB: Where Can You File for Divorce?

Within Illinois, the filing spouse can often choose between the counties where either spouse lives, for example St. Clair County or Monroe County.

Controlling the Timing and Preparation

Filing first lets you prepare on your schedule. You can meet with a lawyer, gather financial records, secure copies of important documents, and plan for living arrangements and child care before the case starts. The spouse who is served unexpectedly often has to scramble.

Asking for Temporary Orders Early

Once a case is filed, either spouse can ask the court for temporary orders on issues like parenting time, child support, maintenance, or who stays in the home. Filing first lets you request these protections promptly, which can be important if your spouse controls the household finances or if there are safety concerns.

Presenting First

At hearings and trial, the petitioner usually presents their case first. This is a minor procedural point, but some people prefer the chance to frame the issues.

Possible Downsides of Filing First

  • You pay the filing fee. The petitioner pays the initial court filing fee, although fees can be addressed later in the case.
  • You show your position first. Your petition outlines what you are asking for, which gives your spouse a chance to see your requests before responding.
  • It can escalate conflict. Being served with divorce papers unexpectedly can feel like an attack. If you hope to resolve things amicably or through mediation, a surprise filing can make cooperation harder.
  • Rushing can backfire. Filing before you have your finances and plans in order can leave you less prepared than if you had taken a few extra weeks.

For couples who agree the marriage is over and plan to work together, who files is often just a formality. Many couples decide together which spouse will file, and some resolve everything through mediation before filing at all.

What If Your Spouse Filed First?

Being served with divorce papers can be a shock, but you have not lost any rights. Here is what to do:

  1. Don’t ignore the papers. In Illinois, you generally have 30 days after being served to file a response. If you don’t respond, your spouse may be able to get a default judgment.
  2. Contact a divorce attorney right away. A lawyer can review the petition, explain your options, and make sure deadlines aren’t missed.
  3. Consider a counter-petition. You can ask the court for your own requests on property, support, and parenting time.
  4. Check where it was filed. If your spouse filed in another state or county, your lawyer can review whether that court is the proper place for the case.
  5. Stay calm and keep records. Avoid emotional reactions, angry messages, or social media posts. Start gathering your financial documents.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the judge favor the spouse who files first? No. Illinois judges apply the same law to both spouses. Being the petitioner does not earn you a better outcome.

Will filing first help me get custody? No. Parenting time and decision-making are based on the child’s best interests, not on who filed.

Do we have to be separated before one of us files? No. Illinois does not require a separation period before filing. See Do You Have to Be Separated Before Filing for Divorce in Illinois?

Can I change my mind after filing? Yes, in many cases. See Can You Change Your Mind After Filing for Divorce?

My spouse lives in Missouri. Where should I file? It depends on residency, where the children live, and how the two states’ laws apply to your situation. Talk with a lawyer before filing.

Talk to a Divorce Lawyer Before You File

Whether you are thinking about filing or your spouse has already filed, the right first step is getting clear advice about your options. Wilson, Dabler & Associates helps clients in Belleville, Waterloo, and throughout Southern Illinois decide when and where to file, prepare for the process, and protect their rights from the start.

Contact us or call 618-235-1600 to schedule a consultation.

This article provides general information and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Guides From A Divorce Lawyer in Belleville, IL

Learn about our practice areas, including divorce, and more about our comprehensive family law practice.

Child and Spousal Support

Parenting Time / Child Custody

Divorce in Belleville, IL

Family Mediation in Belleville, IL 

Marital Property Division

Non-Minor Support

Probate and Estate Revisions

Civil Unions

Wilson, Dabler & Associates, L.L.C.

14 South Second Street
Belleville, IL 62220

Satellite Office (by appointment only)
216 North Market Street
Waterloo, IL 62298

 

Contact Us

618-235-1600
Fax- 618-235-1617

 

 

 

Office Hours

8:30am-5pm Monday-Thursday
8:30am-4pm on Fridays
Closed for lunch from Noon-1pm
After Hours Appointments Available